MedigapGuide
← Back to all guides

What State Has the Cheapest Medicare Supplement Premiums?

The States Where Medigap Premiums Run the Lowest

If you’re shopping for the cheapest Medicare supplement premiums, Iowa, Wisconsin, and North Dakota consistently come up at the bottom of the price chart — and it’s not a coincidence. Rural states with lower healthcare costs and less insurer competition tend to have very different pricing structures than coastal states or high-utilization markets like Florida and New York.

Here’s what the numbers actually look like. A 65-year-old woman in Iowa can find Plan G premiums starting around $95 to $115 per month in 2026. The same woman in Florida might pay $155 to $200 for identical coverage. That’s not a rounding error. Over five years, you’re talking about a difference of $3,600 to $5,100 — real money, especially on a fixed income.

I’ve seen people make peace with high premiums just because they didn’t know comparison shopping was even an option. That’s what this article is for.

State Plan G Monthly Premium (Age 65, Female, Non-Smoker, 2026 Est.) Price Tier
Iowa $95 – $115 Lowest
North Dakota $98 – $118 Lowest
Wisconsin $100 – $125 Low (unique structure)
Ohio $110 – $135 Low-to-Mid
Texas $120 – $160 Mid
California $130 – $175 Mid-to-High
Florida $155 – $200 High
New York $175 – $240 Highest

These are estimated ranges based on 2026 market data. Your actual quote will vary by insurer, age, gender, tobacco use, and sometimes the county you live in. But the directional pattern holds year after year.

Why Some States Are Just More Expensive — It’s Not Arbitrary

Insurance pricing follows claims. States where Medicare beneficiaries use more healthcare services, see more specialists, or live in densely populated urban areas are going to have higher Medigap premiums. That’s the core logic, and it’s actually pretty rational once you understand it.

Florida is expensive partly because of its older population concentration and high volume of specialist visits and elective procedures. New York is expensive for a different reason: it’s a guaranteed issue state year-round, meaning insurers can’t charge more based on your health history even outside of open enrollment. That sounds great until you realize healthy people leave the pool or choose Medicare Advantage instead, which drives premiums up for everyone who stays in Medigap.

Wisconsin, Minnesota, and Massachusetts are special cases worth knowing about. These three states were grandfathered out of the standardized Medigap plan system that applies to the other 47 states. Wisconsin and Minnesota have their own plan structures. Massachusetts has its own rules entirely. Comparing prices there directly to Plan G in Ohio is apples to oranges. What you’re buying is technically different, even if the coverage ends up being similar.

Which brings us to something I want to be clear about: cheap premiums don’t always mean cheap overall costs. You still have to factor in the 2026 Part B deductible, which is $257, and the Medicare Part A deductible of $1,676 per benefit period. Plan G covers the Part A deductible and everything after the Part B deductible is met. If you’re someone who uses healthcare heavily, a low-premium plan that leaves you exposed on the back end can cost you more.

The Biggest Mistake People Make When Shopping by State

I see this all the time: someone moves to a lower-cost state specifically to save on Medicare costs, or they try to use a friend’s address in Iowa to get a cheaper rate. That’s insurance fraud. Don’t do it. Your address on file needs to be where you actually live.

But the more common mistake isn’t fraud — it’s confusion. People assume that because two insurers both sell Plan G, the coverage must differ somehow. It doesn’t. Medigap plan letters are standardized by federal law. A Plan G from Mutual of Omaha covers exactly the same things as a Plan G from Cigna or Aetna. The only differences are price, company financial strength, and customer service reputation.

That means price-shopping is completely logical for Medigap in a way it isn’t for other insurance products. You’re not giving anything up by going with the cheaper carrier. I’ve met people who paid $40 more per month because they recognized a brand name. Over ten years, that’s $4,800 for identical coverage.

The other mistake is conflating state of residency with state of care. Medigap works anywhere in the country that accepts Medicare. If you live in Iowa but winter in Arizona, your Iowa Medigap plan covers you in Arizona. That’s a feature people don’t always realize they’re getting.

What Actually Matters More Than Which State You Live In

Here’s the thing — within your state, the price variation between insurers can be just as dramatic as the variation between states. A 67-year-old man in Ohio can see Plan G quotes ranging from $125 to $175 per month depending entirely on which company he picks. That’s a $600 annual difference for the exact same plan.

Your age at enrollment matters enormously. Most states use attained-age pricing, which means your premium goes up every year as you get older. Some states and some insurers use issue-age pricing, locking in your rate based on how old you were when you signed up. If you’re 65 and healthy, getting into an issue-age policy early can save you thousands over a decade even if the starting premium is slightly higher.

Tobacco use adds a surcharge in most states — often 10 to 20 percent. Gender still factors into pricing in most states, though a handful have moved toward gender-neutral rates. These variables can swing your premium more than living in Iowa versus Ohio.

My honest take: if you have any flexibility in where you retire, the Midwest and parts of the South offer genuinely better Medigap value than the coasts. But if you’re already planted somewhere, the bigger lever you have is comparing every insurer licensed in your state. That’s free to do, takes about 20 minutes with the right tool, and it’s where most people leave money on the table.

High-Deductible Plan G: A Real Option in Low-Cost States

If you’re in a low-premium state already, you have even more reason to consider High-Deductible Plan G. This is a version of Plan G that kicks in only after you’ve paid a deductible out of pocket, which is $2,870 in 2026. In exchange, your monthly premium drops dramatically — sometimes to $35 to $55 per month at age 65 in a low-cost state.

For someone in Iowa or North Dakota who is healthy, doesn’t take expensive medications, and has a little cushion in savings, this can be the smartest move available. You’re essentially self-insuring the first chunk of costs while capping your exposure at a defined number. If you go the whole year without hitting the deductible, you’ve paid very little in premiums and nothing in out-of-pocket costs.

That said, I wouldn’t recommend High-Deductible Plan G to someone who already has frequent hospitalizations, chronic conditions that require specialist visits, or limited savings. For you, the standard Plan G is still the better bet. The math only works in your favor if you can absorb a bad year without financial stress.

Bottom Line

Iowa, North Dakota, and parts of the Midwest and South offer the lowest Medicare supplement premiums in the country — often $40 to $80 per month cheaper than Florida or New York for identical coverage. If you live in one of these states, you’re already starting from a good position. The next step is comparing every insurer in your area, because the spread between the cheapest and most expensive carrier in any state is often bigger than people expect. Don’t pay more for a brand name when the coverage is legally identical.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I buy a Medigap plan from a cheaper state to save money?

No. Your Medigap plan has to be issued in the state where you legally reside. Using a different address to get a lower rate is insurance fraud and can result in your policy being voided when you actually need it. What you can do is use your Medigap plan anywhere in the country once it’s issued.

Why is Medigap so expensive in New York?

New York requires insurers to offer guaranteed issue enrollment year-round, not just during open enrollment windows. This means people with serious health conditions can sign up anytime, which changes the risk pool significantly and drives premiums up for everyone. The coverage is the same; you’re paying a higher premium because of the state’s regulatory structure.

Does where I get my healthcare affect my Medigap premium?

No. Your premium is set based on where you live, not where you get care. If you live in Iowa but see specialists in Minnesota or spend winters in Arizona, your Iowa-priced Medigap plan still covers you with no extra cost. That’s one of the underappreciated advantages of Medigap over Medicare Advantage, which typically ties you to a local network.

Is Plan G really the best plan in every state?

For most people turning 65 today, yes. Plan F is no longer available to new Medicare enrollees as of 2020, which makes Plan G the most complete coverage option. The only thing it doesn’t cover is the 2026 Part B deductible of $257, and after that, you have no cost-sharing. High-Deductible Plan G is worth considering if you’re healthy and want lower premiums, but standard Plan G is the right default for most people in most states.

← Back to all guides